Mosaic Mercy

Loving Gott | Serving Menschen | Building Familie

Posted by David Knapp On March - 9 - 2009

homer and god Saint Homer And Cartoon SpiritualityThe Simpsons

I have been watching this cartoon for 20 years now and in that time I have seen the creators poke fun at Christians but never the Creator God.  I wouldn’t say they never have but from recollection I don’t recall a time when God was ridiculed by ignorance.  Actually the non-follower of Jesus is made fun of somewhat also.  Let’s look at both.

Ned Flanders

This is Homers next door neighbor.  Ned is so very cautious to not offend the Lord.  He says all the right words that always seem to ryhm when he does so.  Basically Ned is the goodie goodie Christian.  He looks like his life is perfect and when something bad happens to him he pretends that everything is alright.  The creator Matt Groening is poking fun at Christians who think they are perfect.  We are not perfect and shouldn’t act that way.  When bad things happen it is okay to cry, get angry and turn to God and ask why.  Don’t be a Ned… even though he is a nice guy.

save me jebus Saint Homer And Cartoon Spirituality

Homer Simpson

Homer just doesn’t get it but he also doesn’t realize that he doesn’t get it.  He and his family attend the same church as Ned.  This is fairly realistic because churches are full of so called holy people and people who are rough around the edges.  Homer only attends church because Marge makes him.  She attends out of respect for God and it is the “right thing to do.”  Homer gets Santa Claus and Jesus mixed up at times.  One of the funniest moments is when Homer is being sent to Africa as a missionary against his will.  Homer starts to panic and tells the pilots that he doesn’t even believe in Jebus (yes that is Jebus with a B) and as the plane is taken off one can hear Homer screaming, “Save me Jebus!!” :D   So funny and yet so true.

godfamilyguy Saint Homer And Cartoon SpiritualityFamily Guy

Seth MacFarlane, the creator of Family Guy, is a man who doesn’t have a clue.  He doesn’t really make fun of the Christian all that much.  He takes his shots right at God.  God can be seen asking women out on dates.  Why would God need to do this?  When is the last time you asked your daughter out on a date?  In one episode they show Jesus traumatized because God sent Him to the cross to die.  Yea, let’s skip the part about Jesus willingly going to the cross to redeem humanity.  Well anyways, another time Jesus is working in a comic book store and looks a little prideful when Peter keeps Calling him the Son of God.

Seth MacFarlane is just really ignorant when it comes to the Bible and the message and he takes his ignorance and puts it into a cartoon.  To be fair he doesn’t stop with Christians and their God.  He also pokes fun at conservatives, people from the south, people from Asia, people from Europe, people who are black, the Jewish community, people who are handicap.  Unless you are a white, liberal, atheistic American who presides above the Mason Dixon line and who doesn’t sit in a wheelchair he will poke fun at you.  And yes I believe he really does hate all those he makes fun of.

saint homer

Saint Homer

Out of these two cartoons I feel that the Simpsons send a better message.  Each and every episode the Simpson family runs into dilemmas.  They struggle to work through the problems like a real family.  By the end of each episode Homer, Marge, Bart, Lisa and Maggie come back together as a family and really realize that they are living the good life and they don’t want to do this life without each other.  Family guy doesn’t really have a conclusion like this.  If I am going to watch one, my pick goes to The Simpsons hands down.

simpson family sticking together Saint Homer And Cartoon Spirituality

If you liked this post, you may also like:

  • None Yet
Categories: Theology

6 Responses

  1. I’ve appreciated The Simpsons from time to time, but own every season of Family Guy. Seth McFarlane is an atheist, so it’s not surprising that he pushes the boundaries of taste with the God concept. I certainly understand how that can be offensive.

    Having seen him interviewed several times I don’t feel that he hates anyone he makes fun off, well maybe President Bush. I don’t see him as making fun of racial groups, but poking fun at the stereotypes, the same for handicapped people, he pokes fun at the way sometimes society can be oblivious to them.

  2. bandnerdtx says:

    Have you read the book “The Gospel According to The Simpsons: The Spiritual Life of the World’s Most Animated Family.” It’s really good and talks a lot about the positive message that the Simpsons sends. You should check it out!

    (Found your blog through Condron.)

    http://bandnerdtx.wordpress.com

  3. David Knapp says:

    I actually haven’t read that book but gave it to my brother for a present. It sounds good. Thanks for visiting the site and also thanks for letting me know where you came from.

  4. David Knapp says:

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Seth. I have seen him in interviews also and for some reason he just comes off as that guy who would pick on me when I was a freshman in highschool. Something just makes me want to knock his books out of his hands and shove him into a locker. :D

    I can see your points on the stereotypes. I will observe it from that light next time I tune in.

    I still see the Simpsons as a whole lot more wholesome.

  5. Oh, I definitely agree that the Simpsons are a a lot more wholesome. I think the target audience is entirely different. If I had kids I might let them watch The Simpsons, but with me around to discuss, maybe once they were older teenagers I would let them watch Family Guy, but I really think it’s targeted at college age and up. Heck, most of the pop cultural references are targeted at people in their mid to late 30’s and up.

  6. David Knapp says:

    I know what you mean about the pop cultural thing. I am six years older than my wife and I understand more than she does about the show because of the generation gap. A lot of their falshbacks in the show have to do with things that are from the 80’s and 70’s.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv Enabled
Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes